On January 23rd. 2024, at about 5:59pm, New Rochelle Police responded to Broccoli Smoke Shop at 394 North Avenue on a report of a menacing with a handgun. Upon arrival the suspect had already fled the scene. At about 7:19pm, Police received a call that the suspect returned. Police responded back and were able to arrest the suspect without incident. The suspect was found to be in possession of a small silver 9mm handgun.
The incident started as a dispute between the suspect and the business owner.
ARRESTED: Isaiah Sutton, 21 years of age, of New Rochelle, NY.
CHARGES: New York State Penal Law Sections: 120.14 Menacing 2nd Degree with a weapon – B Felony, 265.03 Criminal Possession of a Weapon 2nd Degree – C Felony